Blog / JACOB ROBINSON
Things Critics Claimed About GTA VI That Weren't True
(And other first impressions)
Disclaimer: I love this game. I gave it a 10/10. You can see my live in progress notes about it here.
Bad Things That Were Actually Not As Bad
- 30 fps. Now that we get a full scope and understanding of the amount of graphical tech involved here, it is a miracle it is working at any frame rate, much less a stable 30. I’m sure we will eventually hit the tech required for 60 and above but it will probably require brand new hardware and at least an additional 3-5 years of fiddling.
- Main protagonists. I saw a lot of complaining about the quality of the protagonists, but I have a hard time arguing these are any better or worse than previous GTA protagonists. They are meant to be a stand-in for you, the player, so their blandness is mostly on purpose: it allows you to adopt the playstyle you want. Not really a negative in my mind.
- Areas outside of Vice City. Saw several reviews comment that outside of the main town locations there’s mostly nothing to do. From my experience this is totally untrue. Diving into the swamps and forests of Leonida allows you to find all sorts of richly developed environments, hidden locations, strange and unexplainable happenings, etc. etc.
- Immersion concepts. Now, this was always going to be the most controversial piece of GTA VI, since it was always the most controversial part of Red Dead Redemption 2. I could probably write a complete blog post about just this one part specifically. Basically, to sum it up, I love it. I love doing chores and going to the store and buying a fictional latte and drinking it while sitting down at a patio. I love this part. This is some of my favorite stuff about video games, but I can also obviously tell that, for some people, that's just not their thing. It's hard for me to really blame this as good or bad.
Good Things That Were Actually Not As Good
- Pop-in. From the SkillUp review, he had mentioned zero pop-in across the entire game. I have seen pop-in occur every session, especially while driving. Now, I am not a big “pop-in” freak, so I don’t really care: it comes as a natural sacrifice for improving performance, so who really cares.
- Writing. Several reviews noted that this was the best storyline in a Grand Theft Auto thus far. So context, I am at Chapter 3, so I have not seen the whole story yet. But it seems to me they just placed the byline of RDR2 (meeting up with people on your “team” for a chapter, then at chapter end your gang gets attacked and you have to set up somewhere else”). The mystery of the “thing” that set off the mess isn’t really so engaging or interesting that it accelerates the narrative, and the characters are progressing… sort of… but not in a way I find particularly fascinating. I’d put it on par with most other Rockstar narratives: it does the job it needs to.
- Random encounters. Now I'm still digesting this part, but it seems like random encounters are much more confusing than they were before, just because they're now not properly marked. For example, there might be two people having a conversation outside of my apartment, but they're having the same exact conversation every single time they pass by. I get the idea that I'm supposed to do something, but then, when I try and greet them, or try and taunt them, or try to shoot them, etc., etc., etc., no matter what, they just come back and they start talking again. Maybe I'm overthinking this. Maybe I'm just supposed to let these things go and just have them be a part of the world (for example, the random gas station robberies or other things you see on the side of the road). But for these ones that just keep repeating in common places over and over again, I'm not really sure how to approach them or what I'm supposed to do. They can be kind of annoying because it's always a reminder of this always-repetitive thing that just keeps happening, and I'm not sure exactly how I'm supposed to progress into it.
- Immersion concepts. Yes, like all things, immersion is a double-edged sword. There are such cases as "too much freedom," where I go into something really expecting that I'm going to be able to do it. When I'm not able to do it, it totally throws me out of the experience. I'll give you two examples. The first was a mission where it was clearly going to be a drug run gone bad. I was noticing all the NPCs beginning to take their weapons out, so I pre-planned this idea of this little gap between the cars. I was just going to step on the gas, run over two of the gangsters, and then get out of there safe and sound. However, when that time finally came, I noticed my controls weren't working, and it was because the camera had turned around and actually wanted me to go into reverse instead (which, to me, didn't really make any sense). It was also totally against the plan that I had already set up going into it. Another time was when I was supposed to steal a car out of a garage from a bunch of these angry-sounding hillbillies. I decided to just play it safe and execute the three hillbillies stealth style, and then I was going to break into the garage. However, when I got to the garage, there was a door code that was needed that I didn't obtain. I assumed that I was supposed to get it from essentially interrogating one of the people who I had already killed, so I figured, okay, no big deal. I have some sticky bombs. The game taught me that sticky bombs destroy things like safes already, so presumably it's going to work here. I tried it on both the code door and the garage door, and nothing happened. As far as I know, I was pretty much soft-locked out of that side mission.
Good Things That Were Actually Good
- Vast interiors. There are way, way, way more interiors in this game than there have ever been in a previous Grand Theft Auto game. Sure, there are plenty of buildings that you still can't enter, just because the scale of that would be way too big, But unlike in previous games, I never really felt like, "Oh, this is a town, but really, it's just four buildings that I can go into for a rest stop”. In this game, because of how many interiors there are, it really does feel like a full town or a full city.
- Stealth. I never thought I would ever say this, but I have been playing this Grand Theft Auto game as if it was Metal Gear Solid. We've come a long way from the borderline meaningless, completely incomprehensible "stealth mode" that was in Grand Theft Auto V. Every single "outpost" in this game feels a lot like the outposts in Cyberpunk, which I really appreciate because, in that game, one of its greatest strengths was feeling like every sort of individual section of the game was its own sort of nonlinear, immersive RPG (in the same way that Deus Ex is). Now, I wouldn't exactly call Grand Theft Auto Deus Ex, but I feel like the sort of Phantom Pain angle of that is a lot closer to that sort of general concept from a third-person perspective.
- Lighting and Weather. For anyone who played Red Dead Redemption 2, this should be totally unsurprising, but yes, the lighting and weather in Grand Theft Auto VI are absolutely amazing. No notes, just go check it out if you haven't seen screenshots or videos or in-person footage of this game.
Bad Things That Were Actually Bad
- Fitness minigame. Based on reviews, I was really expecting this minigame to be super annoying, and it is bad, but not for the reason they expected. The minigame itself is not annoying. The thing that is annoying about it is that I don't seem to have any place to actually do it outside of Chapter 1. I was really expecting to unlock some sort of gym because that's what I see in a lot of the reviews' video footage for this game, but I haven't found any gym on the map. I haven't been introduced to any gym in the story. I'm sure it will eventually happen. It's going to happen because it was in the footage, but I'm still just sitting on the lowest level of strength because I just haven't had any chance or any ability to increase my strength.
- Engine/Gas meters. This is another system that's bad not due to the fact that it's annoying, but due to the fact that it's pretty much meaningless. Your engine and gas meters never run down to zero, ever, to a point where it's like, "Why even allow me to get my gas if it's never going to be a problem for me?"
Things Left (Mostly) Unmentioned
- Animations. I think the lighting and weather take away a lot of the credit for just how many mocap animations and physics-based animations they must have had to make for this game. As I get deeper and deeper into game development, I begin to realize that the most important and hardest thing to do in a game is animations, because they add so much life and character, but there's no easy way to program it. You have to pretty much do it hand-drawn or via something that's extremely expensive, like mocap. Here, they did a combination of those things. I do want to give them credit for both the acting and also the hand-drawn work of the animators.
- Minigames. One of the big problems with GTA V is that there was a huge amount of minigames that conferred absolutely zero in-game benefit (tennis, golf, etc.) and thus there was no reason to ever do them. Now, I haven’t gotten that deep into VI’s minigames, but it seems like now every single one improves either one of your core stats or improves your cash. So that could be a good sign that the minigames have distinctly improved.
- Load times. There is pretty much no load times for anything in this game. The only “loads” I’ve had to experience is for restarting a race (which I have done many… many times) that takes only a few seconds, and the loads for after you die in the open world which feel like they’re almost there purely for aesthetic reasons. The size and technical fidelity of this game, PLUS no load times? Yeah, I think the 30 fps sacrifice was justified.
- Naturally found missions. So this is an interesting parallel to my problem with random encounters. In the world, if you read flyers or books – if you scroll on social media – if you see billboards, even – you will naturally unlock new missions on your map. I think this is really cool and honestly how the random encounter system should have worked. If you take the time to listen in or overhear a conversation or incident that actually does have more going on with it, it will unlock the mission after you listen to it. Then, if it’s nothing – just random, immersive decor – you don’t have to feel like you’re missing out on a larger questline. Would also stop the same conversations/events from repeating over and over again.
Select text in the article to highlight it.